• Latest News



The Invite: Conversations That Transcend Culture

img

 

The Invite: Conversations That Transcend Culture


A review of Olivia Wilde’s The Invite

 

Have you ever played Euchre? It’s a bit of an old-timer game, but it’s riveting. You are automatically paired with the person sitting across from you, and the pair who can win the most “tricks” wins. Now, naturally there is some deception involved, as is the norm in almost any card game; for the most part, you and your partner should be on the same wavelength, and if you lose the frequency, the tricks begin to fall through and you lose. The Invite is a very long round of Euchre. It follows an evening at the home of Joe (Seth Rogen) and Angela (Olivia Wilde), who invite their noisy upstairs neighbors, Hawk (Edward Norton) and Piña (Penélope Cruz), over for dinner. What begins as two teams sitting across the table transmutes from a desperate show of civility into a sort of muted anarchy fueled by sexual anxieties. It’s a humorous showdown which cloaks the fact that you are watching straight couples argue for two hours, entirely shielded from the flashbacks of your unhappy parents.

 

The Invite is but an episode in the multicultural adaptations of Cesc Gay’s The People Upstairs, and it stands out not just as one of Wilde’s greatest auteurial works, but also in its exploration of the increasingly anxious, postmodern American society. We will not, praise be, regurgitate the existing criticism surrounding the movie in isolation; conversations around the excellent performances of the cast are entirely well-founded but also well-explored. At the very edges and within the crevices of the popular culture narrative surrounding The Invite, however, lies a strong cavity about why these types of Euchre-esque stories exceed all cultures. I come to that question as someone who has lived across more than one of these cultures, which is partly why it nags at me. The Invite is a highlight amongst past adaptations of The People Upstairs because while its structure is universal, it inserts the American culture itself as a third party in the marriage. 

 

There are at least five international adaptations of The People Upstairs; no matter if you’re in Madrid, Seoul, Bern, or Paris, noisy neighbors exist everywhere. So do heterosexual couples. They are rampant, in fact, which partially contributes to the transcultural qualities of the story, and hence it is wrapped nicely into the genre of what we call a Chamber Piece: intimate social stories that don’t rely on excessive staging, props, or much of anything. Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, where the dinner party becomes a blood sport, and Yasmina Reza’s God of Carnage come to mind as similar portable stories adapting to apartment-shaped marriages. They are built upon the universal language of social mortification: the subversion of politeness into the complete relinquishing of social control to complete strangers. The lineage of these stories runs even deeper, from Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice, where the couples are tempted by libertinism (a film WBUR’s Sean Burns opens his review by invoking as the start of the genre), to Woody Allen’s Husbands and Wives.

 

In The Invite we see Angela, presumably a former-artist-turned-stay-at-home-mom, who struggles mercilessly within the contraptions of her marriage with Joe, inviting the upstairs neighbors over to their house. Joe is an insecure, unsatisfied everyman who looks down on almost everyone as a coping mechanism. Angela and Joe frequently hear sexual noises traveling from upstairs, where Hawk and Piña live, and Joe finds the couple unsettling. The Euchre scales of partnership begin to tip unevenly when the hosts quietly concede that Hawk and Piña are the more worldly, more sexually at ease, and overall the more evolved couple. Joe harbors a strong resentment towards Hawk, and Angela finds Piña fascinating; and then we pay to watch what is called the nightmare couple subgenre play out: a pair whose bickering is the entertainment and not upsetting.

 

It’s humorous but not macabre; such are the shortcomings of a heterosexual, failed marriage—a routine grievance in all cultures given its supposed sacredness. And there exists a very thin difference between a mirror and a window, one that is carefully built in a way that places us as neighbors across the street, watching the fights unfold with popcorn in hand and no worry about our own marriages.

 

Yasmina Reza’s God of Carnage, for instance, provides a nice playground for the bickering that ensues in The Invite; though the bland Roman Polanski adaptation Carnage didn’t achieve the same humorous intricacies of The Invite, it belongs to a lineage of drawing-room dramas in which civility is a veneer. In Carnage, two couples meet to resolve a quarrel between their sons and within an hour the parenting talk collapses into insults, spousal sniping, and dissolutions. Despite the different pretexts, the social contract of nicety and politeness is stretched so thin that it snaps, and the characters are effectively disemboweled in front of strangers. And this is the reality that we, the viewers, enjoy. In family-oriented cultures, families are the nucleus of life. Nothing happens beyond its bounds, and containment of information is a virtue. A family-bound culture is also vulnerable to performances, and to keeping up with the Joneses, to an extent that actually exceeds an individual-oriented culture such as the American one. Stories such as Carnage and The People Upstairs can travel between these ideologies because the idea of vulnerability in front of those who fall outside of those culturally defined bounds of comfort is absurdly humorous. Given the context of sex it becomes enticing, even.

 

What is incredible about The Invite is the American ideologies that pull people in directions that are made to categorize but separate. Euchre has two teams; so does polarized America, which is why it’s the most cultural, because American culture is a culture of politics. The American Dream is a political one. Issues of class, race, sexual orientation, gender identity, and social standing exist everywhere, and they feed into and shape disparate parenting styles among parents who are still in recovery from their own childhoods. This is transcultural, and God of Carnage is a beautiful demonstration of how these dynamics expand and tighten in shifting alliances based on identities. Men team up with each other when there’s an issue of accountability, women do so on issues of parenting, and couples swing around the one central idea of adult communities. However, the politics of American culture lies in its unique entanglement with capitalism. Reza’s characters may have inherently different views about many things, but they wouldn’t be encouraged to pay to cope with those differences. The Invite, on the other hand, demonstrates how in highly progressive San Francisco, the pinnacle of American liberalism and the capitalist center of technology, you can be unhappy but able to purchase little bits of false happiness. One credit card-shaped piece of tape for every broken shard of a formerly beautiful marriage. What we watch in The Invite that differs from other adaptations of The People Upstairs is the fact that while marriages fail all the time and couples stray apart, the anxious, capitalist, dysfunctional American society itself is part of the growing gap between Joe and Angela, and, in the versions I have seen, this does not happen in the others.

 

Reza and Polanski agree that the endings of these failed marriages are synonymous with their carnage, and that redemption is irrelevant in their misanthropic themes. The truth that The Invite brings to light deviates slightly from this morbid conclusion. In a nutshell, we learn that maybe love can prevail, if you believe in therapy and can pay a very reasonable $149.99 for every session before insurance. Joe’s foldable bike is the first trinket of consumerism that you see, something you didn’t know you needed, and still are not sure if you do, but will buy. You pay for Spotify, where you can listen to one-sided works-for-all podcasts to attempt to fix your marriage. You can even buy what is advertised as jamón, but is essentially prosciutto; a fake culture sold as the real thing, and apparently we are all buying it. It is in the interplay of these market operations with the very real feelings of love that we experience that the institutionalization of marriage occurs, and couples grow apart because they lose their identities in fabrications of a purchased promise.

 

Being international has the advantage of extra perspective: one that acknowledges why it is so important that Piña is an immigrant, and why her treatment in this movie is so critical to its cultural manifestation. She is seen as exotic and exciting to both Hawk and Angela, representing the Other in terms of nationality and sexuality: the manifestation of bisexuality in Angela, and cultural fluidity for Hawk. Hawk and Piña sharing dialogue in Spanish is an element that is unique among adaptations of The People Upstairs, and those exposed but secret conversations are critical to the barriers between the couples, to those two sides of the table. It is also incredible to have her be in the position of the therapist, professionally and story-wise, because the American story is also one about adaptation. It is an immigrant who brings the knowledge and the exotic and the new experiences into Joe and Angela’s house, and she has to be above and beyond each and every single character to earn her space. She has to be the most beautiful, open, and knowledgeable, and consume the least out of all, and if that is not also the most American thing ever, I do not know what is. Hawk fares similarly with his sexuality. Hawk grapples with identity, “fireman vs. firefighter,” his fluid sexuality and integration into a heterosexual lifestyle that does the same to “others” in sexual orientation and gender identity that it does to race. While Piña is struggling to fit into American culture, Hawk struggles to fit into “straight” culture, and despite the progressive nature of San Francisco and the hosts, the mild disgust and judgment roaming off of Joe is more accurate to a general sentiment of ideological diaspora in an increasingly polarized society.

 

I’ve heard among the criticisms that The Invite is overdone in the first act—there’s over-direction, supposedly. But I raise you this: it has to sell, no? It has to have an exciting trailer, it has to be a true production, because the American audience will not pay a $23 movie ticket, popcorn not included, to see a stage play in movie format. Additionally, I find its appreciation of the medium very darling. The People Upstairs and Carnage are annoying to watch, because there is so little aesthetic, and not much to experience, but Wilde has added a dimension to the story by taking advantage of the soundtrack, long and arduous blocking, set design, and additional directing to maximize the medium. Here, we ask for effort, but we also hate seeing too much effort: had Wilde directed the beginning less, we would have called it lazy, and since she directed it a lot, we call it overdone. If this is not the most American thing ever, I do not know what is. This is why you cannot properly criticize The Invite if you don’t look at the precedents, because the cultural fluency that is required to understand it in many instances falls through with an American audience.

 

None of these tensions, between couples, cultures, or sides of the aisle, gets resolved by the end of the evening, and that is why the ending also matters so very little. Joe and Angela mention divorce, and share a tender moment at the piano over a tune reminiscent of their young love. If the audience were to leave the theater with an answer handed to them, then nobody would contemplate the story itself. The beauty of a thread left untangled is that you can braid it yourself, and that allows you to examine the threads thoroughly, and pay attention to what’s before you. The ending is an interlude for the audience to reflect on what they just watched, not a book snapping shut so we can go home to our sad, heterosexual lives.

 

The Invite may have been playing it safe after Don’t Worry Darling, but the grapple with marriage and relationships is a Wilde testimony through and through. Watching it in theaters, with everyone finding the same jokes funny, resembles a small ritual, one that I suspect would play the same anywhere in the world. These are stories that transcend culture, and relate to our modern experiences regardless of how it fluctuates from border to border. It’s the fact that while none of us get along, we are all the same, and while the problem may be a wrong mix of people in one culture, The Invite depicts a society that does not allow us to truly get to know each other by cloaking what we actually want in what they think we want. It’s a “trick.” The Invite is not perfect, and it is an easy play off a line of successful precedents, but who is to say it is not novel in the way it is so, very American.